Use an Oxygen-Bleach Soak for This Stain

Verdict

Your best match is an oxygen-bleach soak. One OxiClean instruction sheet gives 1 to 4 scoops (2 tablespoons each) per gallon of hot water; check your own tub, submerge the washable item for 30 minutes up to overnight, then launder as usual. Never use it on wool or silk.

Runner-up: Dish-soap degrease

Retake the quiz

Why this fits you

Use an Oxygen-Bleach Soak for This Stain

Oxygen bleach, sold as OxiClean and store brands, is generally sodium percarbonate. Dissolved in water it releases hydrogen peroxide and washing soda, and the peroxide slowly breaks apart the colored molecules in many stains. That is why it works best as a soak rather than a quick spray: the reaction is gentle, so it needs hot water and time. One OxiClean instruction sheet lists a scoop as 2 tablespoons and gives 1 to 4 scoops per gallon of hot water for soaking, and 30 minutes up to overnight for laundry stains. Scoop sizes and directions vary by brand and version, so follow your own label.

Here is the simple routine. Rinse the stain under cool running water first, especially for protein stains such as blood or sweat, because heat can set them; the Soap and Detergent Association's stain guide says to avoid heat until the stain is completely gone. Dissolve the powder fully in the water your label calls for, submerge the item, and leave it for 30 minutes up to overnight for stubborn stains. Then wash it as usual with your regular detergent. Check the fabric before you dry it: if any shadow remains, repeat the soak.

What not to do matters as much as what to do. The OxiClean instruction sheet says to not use it on wool or silk, and Cornell Cooperative Extension says chlorine bleach must never go on wool, silk or spandex, so keep both bleaches off those fibers. Test any colored item first on a hidden seam; UGA Extension recommends testing colored fabrics before using oxygen-type bleaches. Never put a stained item in the dryer until the stain is gone, because heat locks it in. Do not store leftover solution in a tightly sealed bottle, since oxygen-releasing cleaners can build pressure (check your label).

Never combine oxygen bleach with chlorine bleach, ammonia or vinegar in the same bucket, and do not use it as a top-up for another cleaner. Read the label on every product you use and use one at a time, rinsing containers between products. If a cleaning product was mixed by accident, or someone breathes fumes or swallows some, move to fresh air, open windows and call Poison Help at 1-800-222-1222 (America's Poison Centers, US). Call 911 for trouble breathing, chest pain or collapse.

Source: OxiClean product instruction sheet (1 scoop = 2 tablespoons; as hosted on Home Depot's product page); Soap and Detergent Association, Removing Stains from Washable Fabrics (as hosted by Texas A&M AgriLife Extension); Cornell Cooperative Extension, Removing Stains at Home; University of Georgia Extension, Textiles: Products; Missouri Poison Center, Some Things Just Don't Mix. Note: scoop size and soak times vary by product, confirm on your label.

General household-cleaning guidance, not medical or professional advice. The label on your product always wins; never mix cleaning products. For a poisoning emergency call Poison Help at 1-800-222-1222 (US), or 911 if someone has trouble breathing.

How Oxygen-bleach soak compares

Oxygen bleach soakDish soapPeroxide (3%)Rubbing alcoholGentle care
Best forOld or mixed stains on washablesGrease, oil, mud, carpet spotsBlood and sweat on white fabricBallpoint ink, some marker, grassSilk, wool and delicate items
Starting mix1 to 4 scoops (2 tbsp each) per gallon of hot water1/4 tsp per cup for carpet; 1 tsp per cup for grease3% as sold, tested firstRubbing alcohol as sold, on a pad1/4 tsp mild soap per cup of cool water
Time on stain30 minutes up to overnightWork in, blot, then rinseUp to about 2 minutes, then rinseDab and blot, changing the pad oftenA few minutes, then blot
Main cautionNot for silk or woolRinse well so no residue staysCan lighten dyes, test firstFlammable, and test firstDo not rub or soak overnight

* Illustrative starting amounts and notes, rounded -- use the calculators below for your exact numbers, and always check your product label.

Checklist before you commit

Run the numbers

Frequently asked questions

How long should I soak a stain in oxygen bleach?

One OxiClean instruction sheet gives 30 minutes up to overnight for laundry stains, with 1 to 4 scoops per gallon of hot water. Your tub may differ, so follow it. For very stubborn stains, drain and refresh the soak instead of leaving it much longer.

Is oxygen bleach the same as regular bleach?

No. Chlorine bleach is sodium hypochlorite, which must never be mixed with ammonia or acids and which Cornell says never to use on wool, silk or spandex. Oxygen bleach is generally gentler on colors, but the OxiClean sheet still says not to use it on wool or silk, and you should spot test.

Can I use it on old stains that went through the dryer?

Often, yes. A warm soak gives dried and heat-set stains the time they need to loosen, though a few will never fully lift. Repeat the soak once before you give up, and keep the item out of the dryer between rounds.

Other Which Stain Remover Should I Use? results

All Cleaner Calcs tools